I got taken in 
We feasted on olives from the fridge 
We stood the whole lonely day 
We made love all afternoon 
Til the stars went blue 

You wrote a ballad 
We dined on oysters and champagne 
That's it seemed like 
We connect in so many ways 
So easy, I must say 

Why am I so shy around you? 
Why am I so shy? 
Why do I take care to astound you? 
Why do I even try? 

Another rainy day 
We sat inside by the radiator Watching old black and white films 
Where everybody sang 

You played in my solitude 
Didn't get dressed 'til 2 
The rain says all 
I wrote this song on my guitar 
But it didn't turn out right 
So we just connected in other ways 
So easy, I must say 

Why am I so shy around you? 
Why am I so shy? 
Why do I take care to astound you? 
Why do I even try? 

Why am I so shy around...? 
Why am I so shy? 
Why do I take care...? 
Why do I even try?