Boy, I gave you my heart
I gave you everything
God, I've been so blind
'Cause you tore it apart
Let me in the dark
Playing with my mind
But what can I do
The magic of you
It's tearing my heart and two
I'm under your spell
It's heaven or [bad word] It's so hard to tell

Divided 
Like a broken heart 
I'm into deep
Falling apart
Divided 
What's it going to be?
Make up your mind
Or set me free

Boy, you can't fool me twice
'Cause I'm tired of
All the games you're playing
Stop telling me lies
How can I ever [bad word] a word you're saying
But what can I do
The magic of you
It's tearing my heart in two
I'm under your spell
It's heaven, no [bad word] It's so hard to tell