Karen:
I wish you were a bad man
I wish you made it easier
I wish you'd done something unforgivable
 
'Cause holding onto you is that all I can do until
I learn the hands around my throat are my own
 
Don't let me know if it hurts
If it hurts you
I don't want to be your friend that you turn to
That you won't pull me close
But you can't let me go
Don't let me know
Don't let me know
Don't let me know
Don't let me know

Karen & Jimmy: 
I wish I never met you
Now I gotta forget again
I wish you didn't know me
So [bad word] well
Mmmmm....
 
Don't tell me that you're scared
Every time that I'm not [she isn't] there 
Don't you open up my heart again

Karen:
Oh, don't let me know if it hurts
If it hurts you
I don't want to be your friend that you turn to
That you won't pull me close
But you can't let go
Don't let me know
Don't let me know
Don't let me know
Don't let me know
 
If you think there's a chance you can fall again
That you've tried and you've failed to stop loving me

Karen & Jimmy: 
Don't let me know if it hurts
If it hurts you
I don't want to be your friend that you turn to
That you won't pull me close
But you can't let go

Karen:
Don't let me know
Don't let me know
Don't let me know

Jimmy:
Don't let me know