O, my baby, I'm so sad 
O, my baby, I'm so sad 

I heard you got a new boyfriend, I hear he plays the guitar 
I heard he's in the theatre, I'm sure he knows where you are 
If I could only find you and play you this song 
I was writing it the day we met, I've been writing it all along 

O, my baby, I'm so sad 
O, my baby, I'm so sad 

Last night I imagined you standing outside my bathroom door 
But that was almost three years ago, you don't live here anymore 
I put on Neutral Milk Hotel, and fell down on the floor 
I couldn't stand that album back then, now it rocks me to my core 

O, my baby, I'm so sad 
O, my baby, I'm so sad 

O, I miss you so 
Don't ever go 
Don't ever leave me 

I know you're gone for good, I know this time its real 
I know you are still in love with me, you just don't like the way that feels 
I try to remember all the wrongs you've done to me 
But I'll be twenty eight in less than a year 
Back then you were twenty three 

O, my baby, I'm so sad 
O, my baby, I'm so sad 
O, my baby, I'm so sad