Will: 
 Hey, Hey 

 New Directions Boys: 
 Bye, Bye, Bye 
 Bye, Bye 
 Bye, Bye 
 Oh, Oh 

 Will (with Blaine and Jake): 
 I'm doin' this tonight, 
 (You're) probably gonna start a fight. 
 (I) know this can't be right. 
 Hey [bad word] on 
 (I) loved you endlessly, 
 (When) you weren't there for me. 
 (So) now it's time to leave and make it alone 

 Will with Blaine and Jake: 
 I know that I can't take no more 
 It ain't no lie 
 I wanna see you out that door 
 Baby, bye, bye, bye 

 Finn (with Sam, Artie and Ryder): 
 You are my (fire) 
 The one (desire) 
 Believe (when I say) 

 Finn, Sam, Artie and Ryder: 
 I want it that way 

 Will with Blaine and Jake: 
 Bye Bye 
 Don't wanna be a fool for you 
 Just another player in your game for two 

 Will: 
 You may hate me but it ain't no lie 
 Baby, bye, bye, bye... 

 Will with Blaine and Jake: 
 Bye Bye 
 Don't really wanna make it tough, 
 I just wanna tell you that I had enough. 

 Will: 
 It might sound crazy 

 Will with Blaine and Jake: 
 But it ain't no lie 
 Baby, bye, bye, bye 

 Will: 
 Tell me why 

 Finn: 
 Ain't nothin' but a heartache 

 Will: 
 Tell me why 

 Finn: 
 Ain't nothin' but a mistake 

 Will and Finn: 
 Tell me why 

 Finn: 
 I never wanna hear you say 

 Will and Finn: 
 I want it that way 

 Finn: 
 You are my fire 
 The one desire 
 You are 
 You Are... 
 You Are... 
 You Are 

 Will: 
 Don't wanna hear you say 

 Finn with New Directions Boys: 
 Ain't nothing but a heartache (Will: Bye bye bye) 
 Ain't nothin' (Will: Make it tough) 
 But it ain't no lie (Will: Bye bye) 
 Bye bye 

 Will with New Directions Boys: 
 Don't wanna be a fool for you (Finn: You are my fire) 
 Just another player in your game for two (Finn: Tell me why) 

 Will: 
 You may hate me but it ain't no lie (Finn: I want it that way) 
 Baby, bye, bye, bye 

 Will with New Directions Boys: 
 Bye Bye 
 Don't really wanna make it tough (Finn: My one desire) 
 I just wanna tell you that I had enough (Finn: Tell me why) 

 Will: 
 It might sound crazy but it ain't no lie (Finn: I want it that way) 
 Baby, bye, bye, bye 

 New Directions Boys: 
 Bye, bye, bye, bye...