Finn and Rachel: 
Face to face and heart to heart 
We're so close yet so far apart 
I close my eyes I look away 
That's just because I'm not ok 

Rachel: 
But I hold on 

Finn and Rachel: 
I stay strong 
Wondering if we still belong 

Will we ever say the words we’re feeling? 
Reach down underneath and tear down all the walls 
Will we ever have a happy ending? 
Or will we forever only be pretending? 
We will always, always, always be pretending? 

How long do I fantasize? 
Make believe that it’s still alive 
Imagine that I am good enough 
And we can choose the ones we love 

Finn: 
But I hold on 

Finn and Rachel: 
I stay strong 
Wondering if we still belong 

Will we ever say the words we’re feeling? 
Reach down underneath and tear down all the walls 
Will we ever have a happy ending? 
Or will we forever only be pretending? 
Will we always, always, always be 

Keeping secrets safe 
Every move we make 
Seems like no one’s letting go 
And it’s such a shame 
'Cause if you feel the same 
How am I supposed to know? 

Finn, Rachel, and New Directions: 
Will we ever say the words we’re feeling? 
Reach down underneath and tear down all the walls 
(Rachel: Tear down all the walls) 
Will we ever have a happy ending? 
Or will we forever only be pretending? 
(Finn: Only be pretending) 

Will we always, always, always be pretending? 
Will we always, always, always be pretending? 
Will we always, always, always be pretending?