Rachel:
I made it through the wilderness
Somehow I made it through

Rachel and Jesse: 
I didn't know how lost I was
Until I found you

Emma and Will:
I was beat [bad word] I'd been had,
I was sad and blue

Rachel and Jesse:
But you made me feel
Yeah, you made me feel
Shiny and new
Like a virgin
Touched for the very first time

Santana, Finn and Rachel:
Like a virgin
When your heart beats
Next to mine

Rachel:
Gonna give you all my love, boy
My fear is fading fast

Rachel and Jesse:
Been saving it all for you
'Cause only love can last

Emma and Will:
You're so fine and you're mine
Make me strong, yeah you make me bold

Rachel and Jesse:
Oh your love thawed out
Yeah, your love thawed out
What was scared and cold

All:
Like a virgin (hey)
Touched for the very first time (Santana: Hey-e yeah)
Like a virgin
When your heart beats
Next to mine
Oooh (whoah)
oooh, (Santana: whoah whoah)
Oooh (whoah) oooh, (Santana: yah yeah yeah)
Oooh (whoah) oooh, (Santana: whoah whoah)

Santana:
You're so fine
And you're mine

Santana and Finn:
I'll be yours 'till the end of time
'Cause you made me feel
Yeah, you made me feel
I've nothing to hide

All:
Like a virgin, Hey
(Santana: You make me feel like a virgin)
Touched for the very first time (Santana: Ohhh baby)

Santana, Finn, Jesse and Rachel:
Like a virgin
When your heart beats
Next to mine
Like a virgin

Rachel and Finn:
Ooh, ooh
Like a virgin (Santana: Yeahh)

Rachel, Finn, and Santana:
Feels so good inside

Jesse:
When you hold me

Emma:
When you hold me

Jesse:
When your heart beats

Finn:
When your heart beats

Jesse:
When you love me

Santana:
When you love me baby (Rachel and Finn: Oh oh oh whoah)

All:
Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh,
Oh, oh, oh, oh (Santana: yeah)

Rachel and Jesse:
Oh oh yeah

Santana:
Oh

All:
Like a virgin