Tears flowing down my cheek
Tearing me up as I think
Of what could have been

My Ben and Jerry’s melting
Falling apart like me
Dripping down insinuating

What if things had been different 
What if we’d kept it light
What if I could hold you
I wish you’d never lied

What if things had been different 
What if we’d kept it light
What if I could hold you
I wish you’d never lied

I remember clearly you saying
You and me forever
Though I’m still praying

I wanted it to last so desperately
I lost sight of all else
And it ended so [bad word] 
What if things had been different 
What if we’d kept it light
What if I could hold you
I wish you’d never lied

What if things had been different 
What if we’d kept it light
What if I could hold you
I wish you’d never lied

I got dealt a hand
Not in my favor
Not what I had planned
Not what I had hoped for

What if things had been different 
What if we’d kept it light
What if I could hold you
I wish you’d never lied