One girl we passed just tried to stare me down
And when I looked at you, you looked at the ground
I don't know who she is but I think that you do

Dag gummit
Who is she and what is she to you

Something in my heart and in your eyes
Tells me she is not someone just passin' by
And when you cleared your throat was that supposed to be your cue

Dag gummit
Who was that girl and what is she to you

Now when I add the sum of you and me
I get confused and I [bad word] up with number three
You're too much for one girl but not enough for two

Dag gummit
Who was that girl and what is she to you
Who was that girl and what is she to you

Tell me I don't have much intuition
Is that really what you think or are you wishin'
Before you wreck your old home be certain of the new

Dag gummit
Who was that girl and what is she to you

Dag gummit
Who was that girl and what is she to you

Dag gummit
Who was that girl and what is she to you

Dag gummit
Who was that girl and what is she to you