As the evening turns and light begins to fade away 
 Happiness is growing greyer in the wake of day 
 Don your mask and outfit, Ready everything you need 
 Whether you’re a creature, monster, or a demon steed 
 Raise your head up high in preparation for the night 
 Go and head outside, be careful, it’s a chilling sight 
 Sun is starting to set, listen to the children scream 
 Keep your eyes wide open, [bad word] me, this is not a DREAM! 

 Everypony’s afraid, It’s that time of year 
 Get ready [bad word]  when the coast is clear 
 Everything you hate, Everything you fear 
 [bad word] out tonight, SCREAM FOR ME, MY DEAR! 

 It’s fun, it’s fine 
 It’s not like our life is on the line 
 Just Give it time, 

 This is 
 NIGHTMARE NIGHT 
 WHAT FRIGHT 
 GIVE ME SOMETHING SWEET TO BITE 

 Lurking in the shadows, Waiting for an easy prey 
 Something she would never do while in the light of day 
 Still she’s getting worse, in ways no one alive could see 
 Taking ponies hostage with growing audacity 
 But tonight is different, while they’re all dressed in disguise 
 Out at night, and clueless of their impending demise 
 Carrying them off, the filly to the bakery 
 Piling them up then serving them to you and me! 

 Everypony’s afraid, It’s that time of year 
 Get ready [bad word]  when the coast is clear 
 Everything you hate, Everything you fear 
 [bad word] out tonight, SCREAM FOR ME, MY DEAR! 

 She’s lost her mind 
 [bad word] out of time. 
 END OF THE LINE 

 this is 
 NIGHTMARE NIGHT! 
 WHAT FRIGHT 
 GIVE ME SOMETHING SWEET TO BITE 
 NIGHTMARE NIGHT 
 NOTHING RIGHT 
 SOMETHING BROKE, IT’S DELIGHT! 

 Something's not right 
 This quiet town is getting dark tonight  [bad word] FOR YOUR LIFE 

 This is 
 NIGHTMARE NIGHT! 
 WHAT FRIGHT 
 MAKE ME SOMETHING SWEET TO BITE 
 NIGHTMARE NIGHT! 
 FEEL THE KNIFE 
 CART ME OFF AND TAKE MY LIFE