Hands cover whispers of the lovers' fright
Fear-cloaked renditions of that autumn night
Digging [bad word] of the kids in the park
What awful things happened in the dark? 

Take just one last dare
Pretend you don't care
Till twilight falls
Wait, is someone else here?
And I can't stop my tears
I've never been so scared

In the cellar buried 6 feet deep
The lover's shaken from a dreamless sleep
Nails clawing splinters from the ceiling and floor
Shrieking like the witches til his stitches are sore

Take just one last dare
Pretend you don't care
Till twilight falls
Wait, is someone else here?
And I can't stop my tears
I've never been so scared

Calling for the other
Searching for her lover
Secrets she discovers drain her face of color

1, 2, 3, 4, underneath the cellar floor
5, 6, 7, 8, lover will suffocate