You offered your heart with hope in your eyes
You held out your hand for me to try
You were so sure [bad word] you
I thought if I tried I’d feel that way too

So I wrote you a song, threw some words on a page
Signed our names, dated the memories
Placed my love in a scrapbook of you
Sealed with a kiss and an I-owe-you

How do you fall out of love?
How do you tell someone they don’t do it for you anymore?
How do you break the heart of the one you loved?
Is it harder for me? Is it harder for you?
How do you fall out of love?

You begged me to jump, I decided to leap
Hoping my heart would follow my feet
But here in your arms I still feel [bad word] That’s not how love’s supposed to be

How do you fall out of love?
How do you tell someone they don’t do it for you anymore?
How do you break the heart of the one you loved?
Is it harder for me? Is it harder for you?
How do you fall out of love?

I’m still pretending that everything’s fine
But you know me better, you see in my eyes
That nothing’s not nothing, we’re on borrowed time
Before you can break, I’m starting to cry
We danced in your kitchen, we kissed under stars
We laughed in the sun as I fell in your arms
You knew every freckle and loved every scar
I never intended to break you apart

It’s not how I dreamed it would be
And you’re not who I dreamed you would be
And I’m so so so so so so sorry…

How do you fall out of love?
How do you tell someone they don’t do it for you anymore?
How do you break the heart of the one you loved?
Is it harder for me? Is it harder for you?
How do you fall out of love?