Unique: 
I threw a wish in the well, 
Don't ask me, I'll never tell 
I looked to you as it fell, 
And now you're in my way 

Blaine: 
I'd trade my soul for a wish, 
Pennies and dimes for a kiss 
I wasn't looking for this, 
But now you're in my way 

Tina with Unique: 
Your stare was holdin', 
Ripped jeans, skin was showin' 
Hot night, wind was blowin' 

Tina: 
Where you think you're going, baby? 

Brittany: 
Hey, I just met you, 
And this is crazy, 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? 

Tina: 
It's hard to look right, 
At you baby, 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? 

Blaine and Unique: 
Hey, I just met you, 
And this is crazy, 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? 

Brittany and Tina: 
And all the other boys, 
Try to chase me, 

Blaine, Brittany, Tina and Unique: 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? 

Blaine with Brittany: 
You took your time with the call, 
I took no time with the fall 
You gave me nothing at all, 
But still, you're in my way 
I beg, and borrow and steal 
Have foresight and it's real 
I didn't know I would feel it, 
But it's in my way 

Tina with Unique: 
Your stare was holdin', 
Ripped jeans, skin was showin' 
Hot night, wind was blowin' 

Tina: 
Where you think you're going, baby? 

Brittany: 
Hey, I just met you,(Unique: Ooh yeah!) 
And this is crazy, (Unique: Crazy!) 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? (Unique: So call me yeah!) 

Tina: 
It's hard to look right, 
At you baby, (Unique:Baby!) 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? 

Blaine and Unique: 
Hey, I just met you, 
And this is crazy, 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? 

Tina and Brittany: 
And all the other boys, 
Try to chase me, 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? 

Tina and Blaine: 
Before you came into my life 
I missed you so bad 
I missed you so bad 
I missed you so, so bad 

Unique and Brittany: 
Before you came into my life 
I missed you so bad 
And you should know that 
I missed you so, so bad 

Tina: 
It's hard to look right,(Blaine: hard to look right) 
At you baby, (Brittany: At you baby!) 
But here's my number, (Brittany: yeah, yeah, yeah!) 
So call me, maybe? 

Brittany: 
Hey, I just met you, (Unique: oh yeah!) 
And this is crazy,(Blaine: Crazy!) 
But here's my number,(Tina: Maybe!) 
So call me, maybe? (Blaine: Yeah, yeah, yeah!) 

Tina: 
And all the other boys, (Unique: Try to chase me!) 
Try to chase me, (Blaine: Try to chase me!) 
But here's my number, 
So call me, maybe? (Unique: Call me maybe!) 

Brittany (with Blaine and Unique belting:) 
Before you came into my life (Tina: Before you cam into my life!) 
I missed you so bad (Tina: SO bad!) 
I missed you so bad (Tina: Missed you so so bad!) 
I missed you so, so bad 

Unique (with Tina belting): 
Before you came into my life (Blaine: Before you!) 
I missed you so bad (Brittany: So bad!) 
You should know that, (Brittany: yeah!) 
I missed you so, so bad 

Blaine, Brittany, Tina and Unique: 
So call me, maybe?